which was conducted in April and May 2009, sampled the views of 4,087
people in Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Morocco, Lebanon, Jordan and the United
Arab Emirates. According to the respected Zogby polling organisation,
the poll has a margin of error of plus or minus 1.6%. One of the
questions put to the participants was "which two world leaders (outside
your own country) do you admire most?" The most frequently named leader
is Hugo Chavez, at 36%. Following Chavez in order of admiration are
Syrian leader Bashar al-Assad and former President of France Jacques
Chirac (both at 18%), Osama bin Laden (16%), Mohammed bin Zayed, the
Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi (15%) and the current French president
Nicolas Sarkozy (14%).
Admiration in the Arab countries for Hugo Chavez has hugely increased
since 2008. In the equivalent poll conducted last year, Venezuela's
socialist president was named by only 8% of respondents as being one of
the two most admired leaders.
Commenting on this result, the Africa / Americas editor of the US magazine Christian Science Monitor, Matthew Clark exclaimed:
The colorful Latin leftist has some serious crossover appeal.
...It may seem surprising, but a quick look back at Mr. Chávez’s
statements and visits over the past few years reveal why he’s now a
hero for the “Arab Street,” earning nicknames like “Chávez of Arabia.”
In January, Hezbollah chief Hassan Nasrallah – last year’s top leader
of the same poll – lauded Chávez for kicking out the Israeli ambassador
to Venezuela to protest Israel’s military offensive in the Gaza Strip.
“He did this because of his humanity, his sense of revolution and,
in this way, he dealt a severe blow to those who are now hosting the
ambassadors of Israel in their capitals and do not have enough courage
to even think about telling them to leave. “
The same move prompted a Kuwaiti Islamist MP to say that Chávez “has
proved that he was more Arab than some Arabs,” he said. “I call for
moving the Arab League from Cairo to Caracas.”
USA and Israel are my enemies
Covering a range of political, economic and social issues, the Zogby
survey gives an indication of the understanding by the public in Arab
countries of the complexities of international affairs as they affect
the Middle East. Asked to "name two countries that you think pose the
biggest threat to you", 88% named Israel and 77% named the United
States of America. Iran and China came a distant third and fourth in
the list of enemies, at 13% and 9% respectively.
The participants were also requested to comment on the motivation for
Israeli policies and the USA's support for those policies. Although 39%
agreed with the phrase "Israel decides on its own interests and
influences the US", the majority (57%) agreed with one of two
alternative formulations: "US and Israel have mutual interests" (32%)
and "Israel is a tool of American foreign policy (25%).
On the solution to the 'Arab-Israeli conflict', most of those surveyed
(73%) said that they were "prepared for peace if Israel is willing to
return all 1967 territories including East Jerusalem"; but the majority
of those who supported peace on that basis were also of the view that
"Israel will never give up those territories easily".
That view is contributory to the very deep pessimism about the
prospects for peace which the survey revealed. Only 6% expressed a
belief that a lasting peace between Israel and the Palestinians will be
achieved in the next five years; 40% believe that such a solution is
inevitable but will take more time, while 50% think that a lasting
peace settlement will never be achieved.
Shaking the planet
Zogby's 'Arab opinion' survey also reflected a growing concern with
falling living standards due to the economic crisis. A mere 14% of
participants said that they are economically better off now than a year
ago, compared with 54% who stated that they are worse off; and only 33%
are hopeful that their position will improve next year. A big majority
(63%) agreed with the statement that the 'weakened US economy' has a
global effect which "has a negative impact on me and my family".
This disillusionment with the economic results of the capitalist
system, which is indelibly associated with the global domination of the
USA, is without doubt another factor in the increased popularity of
Hugo Chavez in the Arab countries. As Matthew Clark of the Christian Science Monitor wrote in his article on the Zogby poll:
In March, Chávez went before Arab leaders in Doha, Qatar,
to propose an oil-backed currency to challenge the US dollar. There, he
gleefully announced the demise of “the Empire” - or “the Great Satan”
as his friend Mr. Ahmadinejad would call the US. (The two have visited
each other several times.)
“A new world is being born,” Chávez said then. “Empires fall. There is a world crisis of capitalism, it’s shaking the planet.”
This stuff is gold dust in the Middle East.
Mr Clark's sneering tone can be disregarded. It is gold dust because
it is true. And, in Latin America, the Middle East and elsewhere in our
world, more and more people are beginning realise it.