Opinion and Analysis: Economy
Venezuela: GDP Shows Strong Gains in Q1 2011
The economy grew at an annualized rate of over 9%, with the private sector outpacing the public sector for the first time in two years.
Venezuela’s central bank (BCV) has released GDP data for the first quarter of 2011. The report points to an accelerating recovery: GDP grew 4.5% over its first-quarter 2010 level. However, if we want to look specifically at the first quarter of 2011, we need seasonally adjusted data so we can compare it to the quarter just before it. The central bank publishes seasonally-adjusted data, but the data is available only through the third quarter of 2010. There are a few ways we can estimate seasonally-adjusted GDP more recently, using the same adjustment that the BCV uses. We can adjust the overall GDP series directly, or for more accuracy, we can adjust the more detailed series of GDP by industry, and construct an overall series from the results. Figure 1 shows the results of these estimates: first quarter GDP grew by either 9.8% or 9.6% on an annualized basis, depending on which adjustment method we use.
By sector, private sector growth outpaced public sector growth for the first time since 2008, growing at an annualized rate of 13.6% per year. Meanwhile, public sector growth actually slowed from an annualized rate of 4.9% per year in the fourth quarter of 2010 to 2.4% per year in the first quarter of 2011.
The private sector lost about eight percent of its 2008 level of output during the recession, and it still has over four percent of its peak level to grow before it has fully recovered. Public sector output fell by a total of about two percent during the recession, but is now nearly 101 percent of its 2008 level in the first quarter.
Every major industry has made significant gains in the last few quarters, with the exception of oil. It is worth noting that real GDP measures the volume of output, not price, so the high price of oil in the first quarter of 2011 does not factor into this data. Among other major industries, the fastest growing were commerce/repair and manufacturing, which rose in the first quarter at annualized rates of 40% per year and 22% per year, respectively. During the recession, commerce and repair shrank by over 15% of its 2008 level, but began to recover in the first quarter of 2011, recuperating about half of its recession losses. Manufacturing growth has tracked very closely to overall GDP growth in the last few years, and both are currently about three percent below their pre-recession peak. Real estate shrank by about three percent total during the recession, and has gained back nearly all of its losses, rising to over 99% of its pre-recession peak. Finally, general government services saw negative growth for one quarter during the recession (the first quarter of 2010). In the first quarter of 2011 it rose to eight percent above its 2008 level.
Among expense types, the most dramatic growth was seen in imports, which count against GDP growth, and exports. Imports and exports rose by annualized rates of 24 and 16 percent, respectively. Imports have been very volatile during the recession, having lost nearly half of their pre-recession activity by the fourth quarter of 2009, but they have now recuperated about half of their decline. Exports fell by about 20 percent during the recession, and have recovered about a third of the way to their 2008 levels. Again, real GDP does not take price changes into account, so the rise in exports is not related to oil price fluctuations. The rise in imports, together with the rise in private consumption, points to a consumption-driven recovery. This interpretation is consistent with the recent industry rise in commerce and repair and in manufacturing. Private consumption, which accounted for 71 percent of GDP in 2010, tracks very close to overall GDP growth. It lost about seven percent of its 2008 level during the recession, and has recovered about half of the way back to that peak level. Gross fixed capital formation continues to falter. In the second quarter of 2010 it rose dramatically, but it has since fallen almost all the way to its trough during the recession. Finally, government consumption has followed roughly the same path as general government services, slipping only once during the recession and currently running at seven percent above its 2008 level.
Like all GDP estimates, these are subject to revisions. The central bank’s latest releases have included several revisions, with the effect that the recession now looks deeper than it did previously, and the recovery steeper. When the central bank publishes seasonally-adjusted data for more recent quarters, we may see some difference from these estimates.
 The BCV’s seasonally adjusted data (which is currently available herehttp://www.bcv.org.ve/excel/5_2_5.xls?id=109) states that is adjusted using the U.S. Census Bureau’s X-12 Arima module for E-views. Our adjustments are made directly with the X-12 Arima software, available from the Census Bureau herehttp://www.census.gov/srd/www/x12a/.